TBR Breakers

Honest reviews of fantasy, science fiction and horror, each scored out of 100.

Explore

ReviewsLeaderboardBook of the monthSeriesAwards

Reading

Reading nowTBRWrap-upsStats

About

AboutHow I rateContactTakedown requests

Follow

InstagramXGoodreads

Book data from Hardcover

Sign in
Cover of A Dirge for Cascius

A Dirge for Cascius

by Calum Lott

76Search
TBR Breakers
PostsInterview series
Search
  • Review
  • Fantasy

A Dirge for Cascius·Book 1

A Dirge for Cascius

by Calum Lott
76

Review

I’m not going to die like this. Drowning in someone else’s regrets. I don’t want this, but it’s the only way.

By the numbers

How I rate
Emotional impact
85
Enjoyment
72

Comments

Be the first to comment

No sign-up needed. Comments appear once approved; only your name and comment are shown.

More by Calum Lott

All by Calum Lott
  • Cover of Immortal AberrationCover of Immortal Aberration

    My Mortal Memories · Book 1

    Immortal Aberration

    Nov 2025

    Nov 2025

    73

This book appears in

  • Monthly wrap-up

    August 2025 wrap-up

    One of 10 books read

Similar books

  • Cover of Conqueror's BloodCover of Conqueror's Blood

    Conqueror's Blood

    Zamil Akhtar

    Zamil Akhtar

    81
  • Cover of Ironbound
4 starsGreat
764 starsGreat
Cover of A Dirge for Cascius
Cover of A Dirge for Cascius
Cover of A Dirge for Cascius
  • Finished Aug 2025Finished August 2025·
  • 408 pages
Characters
75
Story
72
Pacing
75
Prose
70
World & atmosphere
73
Overall
76

A Dirge for Cascius is a really dark, interesting read. You have a character struggling to battle his inner demons, a great “veteran partnered with a young whiz” trope (Kirella is awesome), an engaging murder mystery, and it’s all set against a backdrop of a wonderfully intricate and fascinating sci-fi universe filled with deep lore.

For me, the best part is Cascius’ struggle with himself and his arc across the story. You probably will need to be in the right mindset to read because it tackles some heavy themes, but Calum Lott does a great job of balancing the darkness with action, and making it worth the investment by the end. I’ll definitely be reading Part II when it releases.

“
I count the day I met her as one of my brightest, right alongside my most precious memories of Efelier and Alosil. She pulled me from a dark abyss I never thought I would return to.” He bitterly swallowed. Never again.“She was the only one I ever dreamed of having a family with. Of having a better life with. And yet it never came. I could not love myself, so how could I truly love them? I tried... I really tried, but I could not heal myself from Alosil’s death. I begged her to stay, not for the first time, but there was a last time. She left and I’ve never seen or heard from her again.”
A Dirge for Cascius, Calum Lott
Comment

Reading log

  • Finished Aug 15, 2025

The blurb

Chaos seeps into the Valsollas Galaxy. Cascius Carcyde is on the brink of letting his addiction to reliving his sorrows claim his mind. When the Sages demand he take a new partner, Cascius must forfeit his old ways in order to solve the twisted Red Hand murders. To unravel an interstellar mystery and stop the Red Hand, Cascius must pull himself from the very depths of despair and learn to change before the entire Velutra falls into oblivion. Stare too long into the abyss, and the abyss peers back. True Detective meets Hyperion in this epic space opera debut, perfect for fans of James S.A. Corey and Christopher Ruocchio. The first part of a duology, this tale is full of inner struggle, fellowship, mystery, futuristic technology, and a galaxy brimming with different races. Some rage against the unstoppable decay of the cosmos, while others stoke the ire of Chaos to bring about the corruption and end of everything.

The feel of it

  • Challenging
  • Adventurous
  • Dark

Readers also tag it: Strong Character Development · A mix driven · Loveable Characters

Moods, tags and content warnings are drawn from readers on Hardcover.

By the numbers

How I rate
Emotional impact
85
Enjoyment
72
Characters
75
Story
72
Pacing
75
Prose
70
World & atmosphere
73
Overall
76

Original rating

I first scored this 7.56 out of 10 and gave it 4.25 stars under my previous rating system. I have since scored it again on the scale I use now, which is the score at the top.

Presentation
8.75
Cover 9 · Artwork 8.25
Prose
7.09
Prose 7 · Dialogue 6.75 · Enjoyment 7.5
World building
7.3
The world 8 · In-book building 6.5 · Enjoyment 7
Characters
7.59
Main characters 7.75 · Surrounding cast 6.75 · Character impact 8
Plot & pacing
7.35
Plot events 7.25 · Plot pacing 7.5 · Enjoyment 7.25
Impact
7.7
Emotional impact 8.5 · Overall enjoyment 7.25 · Lasting power 7

About the book

First published
2024
Length
408 pages
Genres
Fantasy, Science Fiction
  • Goodreads4.27
  • Cover of ArkomaCover of Arkoma

    Valsollas Galaxy

    Arkoma

    Apr 2025

    Apr 2025

    69
  • Cover of Ironbound

    Ironbound

    Andrew Givler

    Andrew Givler

    On the TBR
  • Cover of The Jade Setter of JanloonCover of The Jade Setter of Janloon

    The Jade Setter of Janloon

    Fonda Lee

    Fonda Lee

    80
  • Cover of The Sword of KaigenCover of The Sword of Kaigen

    The Sword of Kaigen

    M.L. Wang

    M.L. Wang

    97
  • Cover of Legacy of the BrightwashCover of Legacy of the Brightwash

    Legacy of the Brightwash

    Krystle Matar

    Krystle Matar

    82
  • Cover of IllbornCover of Illborn

    Illborn

    Daniel T. Jackson

    Daniel T. Jackson

    93
  • And ones I haven’t covered here:

    • The CaptainWill Wight
    • The Wandering Innpirateaba
    • To Flail Against InfinityJ.P. Valentine
    • Mother of Learning: ARC 1Domagoj Kurmaic, nobody103
    • DragonfiredJ. Zachary Pike
    • Aching God: Iconoclasts, Book 1Mike Shel, Simon Vance

    Similar books are drawn from readers on Hardcover.