Every book I finish gets a score out of 100. I score it in seven categories, each out of 100, and weight them by how much they matter to me as a reader. How a book made me feel counts for more than how well it is put together.
Each category is scored out of 100. The percentage is how much of the final score it carries.
How hard the book hit me: whether it moved me, stayed with me afterwards, and made me care about what happened.
How much I looked forward to picking it up, and how much fun I had while reading it.
Every score lands in one of six bands. The meter shows the band at a glance: its notches are the score divided by ten, rounded, in the band’s color.
95+
5 stars
85–94
Stars are worked out from the score. I never set them separately. Every five points is a quarter of a star, so a book’s stars always agree with its number.
Whether the people feel real, change in ways that make sense, and are worth following.
The plot itself: what happens, how well it holds together, and whether the ending pays off.
Whether the book moves at the right speed, without dragging or rushing.
The writing at the level of the sentence: voice, clarity and style.
The setting and its feel: how vivid, consistent and immersive the world is.
Each category score is multiplied by its weight, and the seven results are added together. That is the base score.
Then one adjustment. When Emotional Impact and Enjoyment average above 85, the book earns a bonus: a quarter of a point for every point that average is above 85. It rewards the books that got to me most. The final score never goes above 100, and it is shown as a whole number.
A score is my own reaction, not a verdict on the book. Plenty of books I scored low are someone else's favorite.

An example
Weighted together, these come to 95.38. Emotional Impact and Enjoyment average 96.5, 11.5 above 85, so the bonus adds 2.88. That makes 98.26, shown as 98.
4.5 to 4.75 stars
75–84
4 to 4.25 stars
65–74
3.5 to 3.75 stars
55–64
3 to 3.25 stars
Under 55
2.75 stars and under
Counts are across the 300 books scored so far.
Below 50 the steps carry on the same way: a quarter of a star less for every five points.
Before 2026 I rated books differently. For a while I used a system called By the Numbers: six categories scored out of 10. Before that, a star rating on its own.
So that every score on the site reads the same way, those older ratings have been carried onto the current scale. Each of those books still shows the rating I first gave it, under “Original rating” on its page. I am going back through them and scoring them properly, one by one.
Each was multiplied by ten, rounded down to a whole number, and put through the weights above, bonus included. For a while I scored each category in parts; on those reviews Emotional Impact and Enjoyment, and Story and Pacing, each take their own part.
To the middle of the band those stars belong to: 5 stars became 97, 4.5 became 87, 4 became 77.