TBR Breakers

Honest reviews of fantasy, science fiction and horror, each scored out of 100.

Explore

ReviewsLeaderboardBook of the monthSeriesAwards

Reading

Reading nowTBRWrap-upsStats

About

AboutHow I rateContactTakedown requests

Follow

InstagramXGoodreads

Book data from Hardcover

Sign in
Cover of A Memory of Song

A Memory of Song

by Scott Palmer

86Search
TBR Breakers
PostsInterview series
Search
  • Review

A Memory of Song

by Scott Palmer
86

Review

Man, I love this world from Scott Palmer. The prequel novella, The Sound of Starfall, is one of my favorite novellas I’ve ever read, so my expectations for A Memory of Song were high. Palmer didn’t disappoint.

By the numbers

How I rate
Emotional impact
92
Enjoyment
88

Comments

Be the first to comment

No sign-up needed. Comments appear once approved; only your name and comment are shown.

More by Scott Palmer

All by Scott Palmer
  • Cover of The Sound of StarfallCover of The Sound of Starfall

    The Sound of Starfall

    Jun 2024

    Jun 2024

    87

This book appears in

  • Monthly wrap-up

    April 2025 wrap-up

    One of 13 books read

Similar books

  • Cover of Sons of DarknessCover of Sons of Darkness

    Sons of Darkness

    Gourav Mohanty

    Gourav Mohanty

    86
  • Cover of The Judas Blossom
4.5 starsExcellent
864.5 starsExcellent
Cover of A Memory of Song
Cover of A Memory of Song
Cover of A Memory of Song
  • Finished Apr 2025Finished April 2025·
  • 452 pages
Characters
79
Story
84
Pacing
82
Prose
77
World & atmosphere
87
Overall
86

Adeqor is back, along with two main POVs, James and Wulfee. I liked that back and forth between the two as the story went, it was a nice balance and pacing was pretty well done. Palmer can hit you right in the feels, though, so be prepared. I won’t spoil, but there’s a scene that heavily reminded me of something from ASOIAF and is just devastating.

A Memory of Song is dark, visceral, and emotional—it’s a perfect example of what great Indie fantasy can be. My hype for book two, A Chorus of War, is through the roof.

“
But seeing the person he cared about more than anything else suffering sent James to a dark place. The place that once he fell into, he didn’t know where he’d end up surfacing. James knew it was time to face what he’d spent his life avoiding. He was born a monster. A monster so powerful that folk have tried to wield him like a weapon. His dad knew what he was, and so did Wulfee. That was why they kept people like him and Maggie around. Maggie had told him he didn’t have to be the monster he believed he was. He could see now that she was right. That he didn’t need to carry that around with him. He didn’t need to be a monster. Not then... But times were dark, and the dark was where monsters lived.”
A Memory of Song, Scott Palmer
Comment

Reading log

  • Finished Apr 24, 2025

The blurb

In a dying land, the armies of the dead hold sway. And those who rule them are more god than human.

James Culdaine, the last heir of the Northern Throne, was just a young man when the armies of the South murdered his parents and subjugated his lands. He has never forgotten those responsible, nor has he forgiven. He has spent the last ten years living in isolation with The Feldarra; a sacred Northern clan of fierce warriors, led by the fearless Wulfee who, still reeling from the loss of her own children, finds new meaning in protecting what only family she has left.

Now, an ancient order of warlocks has returned to the North, singing dark songs composed of blood magic that null the elements and threaten all that is living.

With nature depleted and the Southern armies returning to the North, James struggles to embrace the unique power he has long tried to repress; the ability to commune with the spirits of the dead. In the bitter heart of a growing war, with the world dying around them, James and Wulfee desperately seek answers, vengeance, and a way to save the ones they love... No matter the cost.

Fires refuse to burn. The skies are thirsty and breathless. The earth won't eat its rot...

Welcome to Ardura.

By the numbers

How I rate
Emotional impact
92
Enjoyment
88
Characters
79
Story
84
Pacing
82
Prose
77
World & atmosphere
87
Overall
86

Original rating

I first scored this 8.55 out of 10 and gave it 4.5 stars under my previous rating system. I have since scored it again on the scale I use now, which is the score at the top.

Presentation
8.75
Prose
7.75
World building
8.75
Characters
8
Plot & pacing
8.5
Impact
9.25

About the book

First published
2024
Publisher
Nytewood Press
Length
452 pages
  • Goodreads4.02
Cover of The Judas Blossom

The Judas Blossom

Stephen Aryan

Stephen Aryan

93
  • Cover of Seeds of WarCover of Seeds of War

    Seeds of War

    João F. Silva

    João F. Silva

    87
  • Cover of HeraldCover of Herald

    Herald

    Rob J. Hayes

    Rob J. Hayes

    85
  • Cover of Legacy of the BrightwashCover of Legacy of the Brightwash

    Legacy of the Brightwash

    Krystle Matar

    Krystle Matar

    82
  • Cover of The Children of Gods and Fighting MenCover of The Children of Gods and Fighting Men

    The Children of Gods and Fighting Men

    Shauna Lawless

    Shauna Lawless

    81
  • And ones I haven’t covered here:

    • The Dragons of Deepwood FenBradley P. Beaulieu
    • The Last Phi HunterSalinee Goldenberg
    • The Scarlet ThroneAmy Leow
    • A Tide of Black SteelAnthony Ryan
    • Once There Were HeroesPhilip C. Quaintrell
    • A Touch of LightThiago Abdalla

    Similar books are drawn from readers on Hardcover.