TBR Breakers

Honest reviews of fantasy, science fiction and horror, each scored out of 100.

Explore

ReviewsLeaderboardBook of the monthSeriesAwards

Reading

Reading nowTBRWrap-upsStats

About

AboutHow I rateContactTakedown requests

Follow

InstagramXGoodreads

Book data from Hardcover

Sign in
Cover of Priest of Bones

Priest of Bones

by Peter McLean

53Search
TBR Breakers
PostsInterview series
Search
  • Review
  • Fantasy

War for the Rose Throne·Book 1

Priest of Bones

by Peter McLean
53

Review

I think Priest of Bones is a book that will be very polarizing for folks - you’ll either really dig it or not completely enjoy it. I find myself leaning towards the latter, despite initially really liking it.

By the numbers

How I rate
Emotional impact
50
Enjoyment
50

Comments

Be the first to comment

No sign-up needed. Comments appear once approved; only your name and comment are shown.

This book appears in

  • Monthly wrap-up

    February 2025 wrap-up

    One of 12 books read

Similar books

  • Cover of Legacy of the BrightwashCover of Legacy of the Brightwash

    Legacy of the Brightwash

    Krystle Matar

    Krystle Matar

    82
  • Cover of Illborn
2.75 starsNot for me
532.75 starsNot for me
Cover of Priest of Bones
Cover of Priest of Bones
Cover of Priest of Bones
  • Finished Feb 2025Finished February 2025·
  • 352 pages
Characters
52
Story
55
Pacing
55
Prose
50
World & atmosphere
70
Overall
53

First, I think the story stalls in the middle, leaving me almost DNF-ing. If the whole book was like the last 20%, it’d be awesome. Secondly, the first person narration coupled with the character voice being very short and simple, made me want a different style.

But on the positive, if you like gangster stories and a heavy Peaky Blinders influence this might be for you. The world building was enough for me to not DNF and I’m actually glad I didn’t. I’m uncertain if I’ll continue the series, but I do think there are people who would love this book. Definitely try it out for yourself.

“One thing I have noticed in life is that the men who speak the most of honor are usually those who have the least of it.”
Comment

Reading log

  • Finished Feb 9, 2025

The blurb

<b>"The first in an unmissable series, <i>Priest of Bones</i> is a fresh and compelling take on grimdark fantasy. Mashing together soldiers, gangsters, magic and war into a heady mix that is a hulking big brother to <i>The Lies of Locke Lamora</i>."--Anna Stephens, author of <i>Godblind </i></b><br /><br />The war is over, and army priest Tomas Piety heads home with Sergeant Bloody Anne at his side. But things have changed while he was away: his crime empire has been stolen and the people of Ellinburg--his people--have run out of food and hope and places to hide. Tomas sets out to reclaim what was his with help from Anne, his brother, Jochan, and his new gang: the Pious Men. But when he finds himself dragged into a web of political intrigue once again, everything gets more complicated.<br /><br />As the Pious Men fight shadowy foreign infiltrators in the back-street taverns, brothels, and gambling dens of Tomas's old life, it becomes clear: <br /><br />The war is only just beginning.

The feel of it

  • Dark

Readers also tag it: Weak Character Development

Content warnings (2)

Rape · Pedophilia

Moods, tags and content warnings are drawn from readers on Hardcover.

By the numbers

How I rate
Emotional impact
50
Enjoyment
50
Characters
52
Story
55
Pacing
55
Prose
50
World & atmosphere
70
Overall
53

Original rating

I first scored this 5.55 out of 10 and gave it 3.5 stars under my previous rating system. I have since scored it again on the scale I use now, which is the score at the top.

Presentation
6
Prose
5
World building
7
Characters
5.25
Plot & pacing
5.5
Impact
5

About the book

First published
2018
Length
352 pages
Audiobook
10h 28m
Genres
Fantasy, War, Adventure, Epic
Available in
Ebook, Audiobook
  • Goodreads
Cover of Illborn

Illborn

Daniel T. Jackson

Daniel T. Jackson

93
  • Cover of Gunmetal GodsCover of Gunmetal Gods

    Gunmetal Gods

    Zamil Akhtar

    Zamil Akhtar

    88
  • Cover of The Way of EdanCover of The Way of Edan

    The Way of Edan

    Philip Chase

    Philip Chase

    82
  • Cover of Of Blood and FireCover of Of Blood and Fire

    Of Blood and Fire

    Ryan Cahill

    Ryan Cahill

    77
  • Cover of The Children of Gods and Fighting MenCover of The Children of Gods and Fighting Men

    The Children of Gods and Fighting Men

    Shauna Lawless

    Shauna Lawless

    81
  • And ones I haven’t covered here:

    • The PariahAnthony Ryan
    • Kagen the DamnedJonathan Maberry
    • Kings of ParadiseRichard Nell, Ralph Lister
    • Destroyer of WorldsLarry Correia
    • Priest of GallowsPeter McLean
    • The Black HawksDavid Wragg

    Similar books are drawn from readers on Hardcover.