TBR Breakers

Honest reviews of fantasy, science fiction and horror, each scored out of 100.

Explore

ReviewsLeaderboardBook of the monthSeriesAwards

Reading

Reading nowTBRWrap-upsStats

About

AboutHow I rateContactTakedown requests

Follow

InstagramXGoodreads

Book data from Hardcover

Sign in
Cover of What Comes Before

What Comes Before

by Molly Macabre

82Search
TBR Breakers
PostsInterview series
Search
  • Review

What Comes Before

by Molly Macabre
82

Review

I’m going to find a way back to you, mom. I promise.

By the numbers

How I rate
Emotional impact
87
Enjoyment
87

Comments

Be the first to comment

No sign-up needed. Comments appear once approved; only your name and comment are shown.

More by Molly Macabre

All by Molly Macabre
  • Cover of Without A WhisperCover of Without A Whisper

    Songs of the Tangled Elegies · Book 2

    Without A Whisper

    Jan 2026

    Jan 2026

    83

This book appears in

  • Monthly wrap-up

    August 2025 wrap-up

    One of 10 books read

Similar books

Readers of What Comes Before also go for:

  • Born to Be Hanged: The Epic Story of the Gentlemen Pirates Who Raided the South Seas, Rescued a Princess, and Stole a FortuneKeith Thomson
  • The Stranger in the LifeboatMitch Albom
  • Act Like a Lady, Think Like a LordCeleste Connally
  • The Booklover's LibraryMadeline Martin
  • Every Day I Read: 53 Ways to Get Closer to BooksShanna Tan, Hwang Bo-reum
  • The Secret Book SocietyMadeline Martin

Similar books are drawn from readers on Hardcover.

4.25 starsGreat
824.25 starsGreat
Cover of What Comes Before
Cover of What Comes Before
Cover of What Comes Before
  • Finished Aug 2025Finished August 2025·
  • 124 pages
Characters
76
Story
77
Pacing
85
Prose
74
World & atmosphere
78
Overall
82

This is going to be another hit for Molly Macabre. For horror fans, there’s several comfortable tropes that are done really well. But what Macabre excels at is creating a tense and smothering atmosphere. What Comes Before is paced like a great horror movie, but the entire time you feel the overwhelming dread and uncertainty of Tess and Aiden.

It’s a blast to read and I felt like I knew exactly where things were going, but Macabre throws almost everything on its head. By the end, I had a true “WTF” moment, which is what I love to have in a horror story. This is a no-brainer for horror fans, but I think almost everyone would find something to love here.

“
The skin around her nails was blistered and peeling away with yellow liquid weeping from the deep craters. Chunks of her fingertips were gone, leaving only fatty tissue hanging from them. In some places, white, glossy bone peeked through what was left of her flesh.“Oh, God,” Tess whimpered. “No, no, no. I can’t do this. This place is going to kill us!” She held her mangled, quivering hands out in front of her.“It’s not going to kill us,” Aiden said without emotion. “It’s just going to make us wish we were dead.”
What Comes Before, Molly Macabre
Comment

Reading log

  • Finished Aug 6, 2025

By the numbers

How I rate
Emotional impact
87
Enjoyment
87
Characters
76
Story
77
Pacing
85
Prose
74
World & atmosphere
78
Overall
82

Original rating

I first scored this 8.09 out of 10 and gave it 4 stars under my previous rating system. I have since scored it again on the scale I use now, which is the score at the top.

Presentation
9.25
Cover 9.25
Prose
7.43
Prose 7.25 · Dialogue 7.5 · Enjoyment 7.5
World building
7.85
The world 8 · In-book building 7.5 · Enjoyment 8
Characters
7.6
Main characters 7.25 · Character impact 8
Plot & pacing
8.1
Plot events 7.75 · Plot pacing 8.5 · Enjoyment 8
Impact
8.55
Emotional impact 8.75 · Overall enjoyment 8.75 · Lasting power 7.75

About the book

First published
2025
Publisher
Independently published
Length
124 pages
Available in
Ebook
  • Goodreads4.33
  • Cover of Dark BloomCover of Dark Bloom

    Songs of the Tangled Elegies · Book 1

    Dark Bloom

    Dec 2024

    Dec 2024

    87